Thursday, February 18, 2021

Venahapoch Hu - ונהפוך הוא - When Chasidim Become Misnagdim - The Stories Less Heard

There is a quite interesting book that came out within the last year, a biography of the great Rav Noach Weinberg z"l of Aish HaTorah fame, by the well known scribe Yonason Rosenblum.

In the beginning of the book, in a chapter on his roots, an interesting aspect of R. Noach is mentioned. There it is related that he used to remark in his later years that despite his eminent Chasidic roots (he was a great-great grandson of the first Slonimer Rebbe, with close connections to other Rebbes and Chasidim as well), 'somehow he was born a Misnaged' (p.25). It goes on to say that when his father used to try to relate Hasidic tales to him as a youngster, he resisted. Perhaps, as a person who determinedly sought אמת, even in his youth he was put off by the questionable veracity of "Chasidishe Mayses", a genre notoriously credibility challenged, as stated by great Rebbes themselves (documented here in the past, see e.g. here, and here). 

The point I want to make, however, is that this brings to light something that exists, but perhaps is not as well known as it should be. Namely the phenomenon of Chasidim, people of Hasidic descent, going Litvish, taking a non-Chasidic path, joining the non-Hasidic frum world. While there is a Hasidic genre going back to the early days of the Hasidic movement of tales of non-Chasidim that became Chasidic, the other side of the coin, the reverse phenomenon is not as well known. But it definitely exists, and has for a long time, encompassing many, many people, בע"ה, from banshakim (plural of בנש"ק = בנן של קדושים, a Chasidic expression for those of Rebbishe descent), to common Chasidim. Perhaps for various reasons, people involved and in the know didn't dwell on, make an avodah of such stories, as Chasidim did with their opposite numbers. Anyway, Rav Noach is just one person in that category, in his close circle alone there are multiple similar examples, some prominent ones being his brother R. Yaakov Weinberg z"l, his Rosh Yeshiva Rav Ruderman z"l, and on and on. In an earlier time, a very prominent example was the great gaon R. Aizel Charif of Slonim, and of course there was the Steipler Gaon not so long ago. And there are many Chasidim influenced by the Litvishe world, in various other ways, even if they don't openly switch over (something that can be difficult for some, due to family ties, and other factors).

Since we are now in the month of אדר, approaching the great Yom tov of Purim, the season of ונהפוך הוא, it is a good time to turn the regular perspective around, and look at the other side of the coin. 

A bit to whet the appetite. ואידך זיל גמור.


א פרייליכען חודש


Monday, February 8, 2021

Another Breslov Song In Disguise From Yehudah Green - Di Rebbe Iz Do | יהודה גרין - דער רבי איז דא

 I recently saw a new music video by well known, talented singer Yehudah Green being promoted online, which caught my attention, but some time passed before I actually played it. 

The song is entitled "Yehuda Green - Di Rebbe Iz Do | יהודה גרין - דער רבי איז דא" ("The Rebbe is here"), and the words sung are mostly in Yiddish, with some Hebrew tacked on near the end. 

But what type of רבי is meant? First I thought it might be a yeshiva rebbe, like a teacher of לימודי קודש in a classroom. But I quickly realized that was not the case, when the song made reference to Chasidim vis-à-vis the Rebbe. Obviously it was a Chasidic Rebbe, an אדמו"ר that was meant. But still, I was wondering about the background of the song. From the lyrics one understood that the song was addressing Chasidim gathering in the (physical) absence of their Rebbe, that were comforting themselves by maintaining that the Rebbe is nevertheless with them, despite not being seen. But I was still wondering about where the song was coming from. A clue came from one of the words used in the (predominantly) Yiddish section, קיבוץ (gathering), a word used by Breslover Chasidim for their Rosh Hashana gathering in Uman, which is otherwise not heard much in such context among חרדים (perhaps because over time it came to be commonly associated with a different type of kibbutz). I also recalled the Breslov roots of the singer, Yehuda Green, and a previous song of his with an undisclosed Breslov background that we posted about here a number of years ago.

To try to confirm my hunch about the song, I did some searching online, and guess what, voilà! I found a comprehensive report on the background of the song at a Breslover website. According to it, the song came together around this past ראש השנה תשפ"א, when many Breslovers could not go to Uman, due to the COVID-19 situation, and some instead gathered in Ramot, ירושלים עיה"ק. Along with the video of the Yehuda Green version of the song, it has a recording of an earlier (or the original) version of the song, in which the Breslov context and background of it is explicit. In that earlier version, the lyrics state that at every kibbutz of Breslover Chasidim, the Rebbe (R. Nachman of Breslov) is there, as R. Nosson (R. Nachman's student/successor) said. In the later Yehudah Green version, on the other hand, it just says Chasidim סתם, and 'as the תלמיד said' instead of 'as R. Nosson said'.

As with the earlier song mentioned, evidently with the latter as well, an effort was made to obscure the Breslov background of the song in the Yehudah Green version, to give it greater appeal to a broader audience.

Due to the commonalities between the two cases, my verdict remains the same as previously stated: Not for Litvaks. :)

א גוטען חודש

Tuesday, December 22, 2020

Rav Avigdor Miller Warns Against Unwholesome and Dangerous Distortions in Torah Study

A few months ago, in the 5781 שבת שובה Toras Avigdor booklet (p.6-7), Rav Avigdor Miller ז"ל addressed some dangerous distortions in Torah study and teaching, that exist among some Torah students and teachers, including, unfortunately, some identified with the Litvishe community, that can lead to Torah impoverishment and alienation, G-d forbid.

In particular, two distortions were described.

1) Covering too little ground. Getting bogged down in a Talmudic thicket, and not getting to know the vast, beautiful forest around it. It is very important to have context, to get the proverbial big picture, in Torah as in life, for proper understanding, and one doesn't get that from a relative few pages.

Rav Avigdor Miller states emphatically, based on his experience in great ישיבות of the past, that learning Torah does not mean learning merely the first six blatt of a מסכת, albeit with "all rishonim and achronim" in a winter zman. Rather much more was learned. As Rav Miller states, essential Torah principles and wisdom are not limited to the most widely studied pages of  Talmudic tractates, but rather appear throughout the vast Talmudic sea (ים התלמוד). And through the תוה"ק in general, of course.

2) Skipping "non-lomdish" sections of gemara. Rav Miller speaks harshly of a rebbi he once had, that, when they came to sections of the Talmud that were not "legalistic", but rather dealt with חכמה, מוסר, eitzos, and yiras shamayim, he would skip them (!).

A wholesome Torah education leads to a wholesome Torah personality. A fragmented and piecemeal Torah education can lead (G-d forbid) to a deficient, semi-educated, fragmented, immature product.

As the saying goes, a little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

May Hashem help us learn and grow appropriately.

Aftermath of Chabad-Lubavitch "Miracle Torah" - Dramatic Crown Heights COVID Increase

Look at what the situation is now.

People who were part of the scam, either knowingly, or duped into it, should speak out now and renounce it. Whether a maggid, a Rabbi, or one of the few Roshei Yeshiva, wake up, and be מתחרט for joining up with Lubavitch and leaving the path of Rav Schach זצ"ל.

ושב ורפא לו

Wishing אחב"י a רפואת הנפש ורפואת הגוף בתוך שאר חולי ישראל.

Monday, December 14, 2020

Neo-Chasidus Guitar Hallel in the Spotlight

 One of the trademark innovations of Neo-Chasidus (in addition to the Tisha B'Av kumzitzes) is its Hallel with musical instruments playing. Mostly guitars it seems, but there could be other instruments too. Such things can be seen on Rosh Chodesh, and on various Yamim tovim.

Now, not everyone realizes that the propriety of such a service is not a simple matter. Significant halachic authorities do not permit such things, for various reasons.

A short time ago, I noticed a post at the Life in Israel blog, related to this. According to it, a dispute erupted after someone came into a minyan with a violin and started playing it during Hallel. Later on, they agreed to ask a שאלה to a מורה הוראה about it.  The question was posed to Rav Shlomo Aviner, a leading Dati-Leumi Rabbi, and he said that it should be avoided.

I am writing this to call attention to this matter, but also in general to the innovations of Neo-Chasidus, which some people do not seem aware of, which warrant scrutiny. As we see here, even in the Dati-Leumi camp, there exists opposition to (at least some of) their actions.

A freilechen Yom Tov.

Wednesday, December 9, 2020

Preserving the Great Legacy of Rav Schach זצ"ל - Social Distancing From Deceit & Falsehood

Rav Elazar Menachem Man Schach, זצ"ל, was a great תלמיד חכם and builder of Torah. In his later years, in particular, he also was a מנהיג of masses of Yidden at large, and an important source of דעת והשקפת התורה הקדושה for כלל ישראל.

A crowning achievement of the rich life of Rav Schach זי"ע was when he stood up, in his old age, with great sacrifice, against the dangerous messianic movement of Chabad-Lubavitch, based in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, in New York, and, with the help of הקב"ה and many clear thinking Jews, succeeded in raising awareness of the great danger of it, and the imperative of social distancing from them, for protection against infection from their confused and distorted beliefs and actions.

Rav Schach zt"l, however, was niftar (passed away) close to twenty years ago, and, since then, in the passage of time, the understanding of the necessity of continuing this distancing weakened among some, for example, among younger people, who hadn't seen the dangerous messianism at its peak up close themselves. Since Chabad-Lubavitch is based in a neighborhood in New York away from where most frum Jews live, it is easy for people to delude themselves into wishful thinking that Chabad-Lubavitch messianism is an issue of the distant past, not relevant today, as they may never have visited 770 Eastern Parkway and seen the lunacy there. At the same time, Chabad-Lubavitch and their fellow travelers have tried to rewrite history, cover up that past, break out of their isolation, and be accepted as part of the mainstream Klal Yisrael, especially among the more Orthodox and Haredi ציבור.

As a consequence of the above, there have been more incidents, ל"ע, in recent years, of breakdowns in necessary distancing from Chabad-Lubavitch.

             Chabad-Lubavitch "Miracle Torah" of Fraud & Deceit

Recently, taking advantage of confusion and desperation during the Corona virus outbreak, a giant "Miracle Torah" (at other times called Unity Torah, or United for Protection) scam was run by Chabad-Lubavitch from Crown Heights. Fierce debate about the project was seen in various places online With the help of massive advertising and PR (typical of Chabad, as they were taught by their late Rebbe), a significant amount of people were induced to give a great amount of money for a dubious סגולה alleged to be from the founder of Hasidism, with the implication being that it would stop COVID-19 in its tracks miraculously. The organizers attempted to hide the project's connection with Chabad-Lubavitch, to make it seem like a mainstream community endeavor, when soliciting support from outside their group. They succeeded thus in duping some non-Lubavitch community leaders, even some Rabbis, with this duplicitous and deceptive approach. ב"ה many of our leaders saw through the Chabad-Lubavitch deception, and almost all Litvishe leaders did not fall into it. Overall, though, too many people were confused by it, so it is necessary to alert people, not only since it is has not ended, as they are attempting to continue it, by getting people to contribute more for another such "Miracle Torah", but also to alert people in general to the danger of this sect and their devious ways, to protect against other, similar present and future dangerous initiatives.

         Why is the Chabad-Lubavitch "Miracle Torah" a scam?

Let's look at the results -

Firstly, in contrast to the implication of the Chabad advertising that the COVID-19 plague would end even before the Torah was finished, when the Torah project was merely underway, as the tale it was based on, the plague has continued for months, with victims upon victims.

Secondly, even after the "Miracle Torah" was finished earlier this week, and the extravagant celebration ended, Lubavitch media itself, just the other day, reported that COVID-19 was endemic in Crown Heights!

Where then, is the miracle? 

They concealed the fact that it was a Chabad-Lubavitch project

They were mevazeh מרן שר התורה, R. Chaim Kanievsky שליט"א, by presenting him a distorted version of their project (they hid from him who it was from, that it is a Chabad-Lubavitch project, and hid from him that it was being advertised as a "Miracle Torah" - real גניבת דעת, which I suspect was done to other Rabbis too - shame on them, הוי זהיר בגחלתן, such deception and בזיון of a גדול בישראל, a מנהיג הדור, is a very dangerous "game" to play, even if they paid off people to assist them in it) and using it to get an "endorsement" from him based on that deception. There are two videos with Rav Chaim - one from months ago, and a more recent one. In both of them (it seems that they paid off Reb Y. M. Druk and Yanky Kanievsky to get a sham "endorsement" under false pretenses from Rav Chaim שליט"א - watch the videos closely and you can see how the whole thing looks like a big setup - א שאנדע און א חרפה) he is asked about writing a Torah for a זכות for protection from the virus - a "miracle" is not mentioned.

When the project was already well established, their Lubavitcher roots and agenda became more visible, such as when they went to the grave of the late Lubavitcher Rebbe right before the "Miracle Torah" was finished, and when the first leining of it took place at 770 Eastern Parkway, the morning after the dedication.

                    Was It An Official Chabad-Lubavitch Project?

While it seems that originally it was an initiative of individuals rather than "official Lubavitch", later on, the Chabad establishment got involved, to the extent that people like Reb Moshe Kotlarsky, and the brothers Reb Simon and Reb Y.Y. Jacobson took part in the big celebration

                                    "Miracle Torah" vs. "Unity Torah"

The massive publicity promoting the project alternated between calling it "Miracle Torah" and "Unity Torah". Why was "Unity Torah" sometimes used instead of "Miracle Torah"? Perhaps the organizers realized that calling it Miracle Torah left them too open to charges of running a scam. However, it also points to another aspect of the project. The hidden messianic agenda involved. Chabad-Lubavitch has been promoting the writing of Torahs for decades to unite Yidden  and to bring Moshiach. Despite the special COVID-19 angle of this one, the Chabad-Lubavitch mission to write "unity Torahs" to "bring Moshiach" was also a big part of it, whether explicitly acknowledged, or not.

              A Teachable Moment - Takeaways from this episode

Beware of scam artists, even if they look "frum".

Sholom Mordechai Rubashkin was used to promote this. It should be made clear by now though that Rubashkin is not a מורה דרך for the general ציבור. Whatever ordeal he went through, he remains a Lubavitcher, with the continuing mission and goal of trying to spread Chabad-Lubavitch Chasidus, and the honor of their late Rebbe, to the world at large. It is time to stop the veneration of him as some kind of Jewish leader, when he gives shiurim at 770 Eastern Parkway, Messianic Lubavitcher HQ, with its giant 'Long live the Rebbe...'  banners in the background, and when he referred to the late Rebbe with the expression שליט"א many years after his passing.

Keep a distance from Chabad Houses. If you travel, make other arrangements for food and davening. Do not compromise important Torah principles for the fleeting convenience of Lubavitch facilities.

                                            Some Good News

 Despite their massive event/webcast for over six hours earlier this week. the amount of letters subscribed to in their second "Miracle Torah" only rose about two percentage points, from about fifteen to seventeen percent. That seems to show that people are wisening up to their scam, and/or that the more gullible folks have already been had, and are thinking, enough!

In the merit of sticking to אמת, and staying away from falsehood and deceit, even when it is cloaked in "frum" garb, may we merit good health and the true משיח, soon, in our days.

May the light of Chanukah drive away the darkness of שקר.

A freilichen Chanukah.

P.S. Just saw an interesting Op-Ed at a Lubavitch site, where the project came under fire from within Habad for allegedly not being Lubavitch enough. Maybe that is why they came more out of the closet afterward.